Get Better Email Marketing Results Today in Chelsea

Beyond My Ken, CC BY-SA 4.0 <>, via Wikimedia Commons

Chelsea: Constantly Evolving

Wow, Chelsea. What can I say, Chelsea was a mecca when I first moved here in the late 90s. A little gay boy escaping from the Midwest to find a place he could belong. Chelsea was that for awhile. But, Chelsea, true to its nature changed.

If you look at the history of Chelsea, it's a testament to change. In the 1960-70s, the neighborhood fell on hard time. From the late 1970s to early 2000s, it was the center LGBTQ life in New York. As acceptance grew of LGBTQ community, the need for a ghetto lessened. Chelsea's heart migrated a bit west of 8th avenue when the Highline was opened in late 2010s. It's now dotted with luxury housing, and many flock to the little garden space in the middle of the city.

The marketing challenge with Chelsea is the same with most of Manhattan is the constant flux. The ebb and flow as neighborhood evolve and change.

Why Web Design is Important in Chelsea?

In a changing neighborhood, mobile responsiveness and speed are both key to letting both new and old customer know where you are and what you do.

  1. Web design needs to be fast. If not, after 3 seconds, that customer is lost.
  2. Next, a web design needs to be intuitive so it easily raises awareness among the newcomers or reminds the locals that your business exists. 
  3. Mobile responsive is key so no matter which device they use, your customers know that you are nearby, open, and accessible - just around the block.

Headline is the Key 

Over 50% of people will open an email if it has a compelling headline as reported by the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism.

Key to a Good Headline

We believe that there are three essential elements to a good headline:

  • Conciseness. 
  • Utility. 
  • Urgency.
email marketing for small business subject line is everything

Headlines are very hard to write well because there is a lot of information to squeeze in a 55-60 characters. This is why we narrowed them down to 3.


Of the three, utility is the most important. Making it clear that this email is worth reading is job number 1.  If your title doesn’t make it clear to the reader what is in it for them, rewrite it. 

Many people can write the headline so the utility is clear but the headline is too long, which leads the next point.


This is where it gets even tougher - how to condense your utility in 3 or 4 words. This is where keywords can be helpful. People are searching every day for information about your topic, so you can leverage those searches to see which terms they use most often. They are generally a very good predictor of which words will work best.


Now, we come to our last point, urgency. Of the hundreds of emails a person receives in a day, we need to convince them as to why they should read ours now. We’ve become so desensitized to “now”, “today”, etc. that they have lost their impact.

Real offers with deadlines do still work. Deals or other incentives or limited access to an event still deliver.    

Respect Your Reader’s Time

email marketing for small business brevity is key

The last thing you want after creating a great headline to boost open rates is to lose them with poor design. 

Email design follows the same principles of web design.  Communication is messy, and design helps aid in getting our intended message across quickly and efficiently.

An email is an intrusion. We need to recognize this fact. Therefore, we need to make that intrusion as brief and clear as possible by sticking with one clear message.

We cover email design in great detail in our post on small business email marketing. We will just touch on the high points here.

email marketing for small business communication is messy

Design Choices Can Help or Harm Communication

Using color remains more of an art than a science, even though we have studied it since the ancient Greeks.

The challenge with color is context. Some colors, such as blue/green, are seen as pleasing when in an environmental setting, but as disgusting when on bread as mold.

Therefore, the first thing we need to consider with color is context. The next is harmony. 

Color should enhance, not detract or compete with your message. Color used well can be attention grabbing, which used poorly can be overwhelming.

Tools like the color wheel can help. The color wheel is based on the harmonics of different wavelengths of light. Just like music, some notes sound better together, while others sound like noise.

Creativity Wins Points.

According to Best Designs, original graphics are the most successful. 

“Original graphics make up 40% of all successful visual content that accomplishes marketing goals, but 43% of marketers struggle with the consistent production of captivating visuals.”

Since we are communicating one message, the artwork that supports it must work very hard to support the message. This is where local market know-how can really help. Original photos and images of your business in Chelsea interacting with your neighborhood can add value.

It also helps with when your calls to action focus on local events in and around Chelsea or at your business location.

email marketing for small business call to action

Call to Action

Every email, no matter how trivial, should have a call to action. This is where all the hard work above pays off. If we omit one, we just wasted resources that could have been spent more cost effectively.

We cover email list building in great detail in our post on small business email marketing. Again, we will just hit the highlights here as it pertains to Chelsea. Every neighborhood has summer fairs. While these were severely impacted by COVID, in our post COVID world they should roar back with a vengeance. It would be smart to see if you could piggy-back off one or more of them.

Incentives, deals, free trials, and samples are all great options when developing your calls to action. See if you can partner with your neighbors to create a shared promotion. This way one shopper in Chelsea has two or more places to visit while out in the neighborhood.

Why Local Digital Marketing is Important in Chelsea?

In a changing neighborhood, , the first decision you need to make is deciding on your target. With influx of new people and the shift in business heart, it's more important than ever to be seen and stand out. Your old customers may have left, but now, it is time to find someone new.

  1. Local digital marketing in Chelsea is about choose whom among the newcomers you with to target.
  2. Next, it is important to raise awareness among the newcomers or remind the locals that your business exists. 
  3. Local digital marketing alerts the newcomers that you are nearby, open, and accessible - just around the block.

Creating & Building an Email List

When building a list, the worst thing you can do is use SPAM like tactics. It can harm your credibility and damage your brand. However, it is good to be aware that others will and do, so it is alway important that we focus on our value.

There are two main tactics that we have seen work time and again.

  1. Create an Amazing Incentive for your readers.
  2. Have an Email Signup Form where people can easily see it.

email marketing for small business cultivating your email list

As we mentioned, one of the beauties of email is its low cost However, there is a hidden cost, which is the caring and feeding of your list. 

How you go about list management depends on how much of the steps above you plan to do in house. 

As a small business owner, it is hard to dedicate the time to do all that is suggested. 

Full disclosure, ProStrategix is a full service digital marketing agency, so this is what we do. Therefore, it will come as no surprise that we advocate for the use of a knowledgeable 3rd party. 

That said, there are many software programs and marketing automation tools that can help manage your email marketing campaigns. You would have to invest the time and energy in writing and developing the emails, but the tools could manage the campaign.


In closing, I hope you see how these 3 email marketing email marketing hacks can help. To review:

  1. Headline is Priority #1: Remember that ½ of the people will decide whether to open or delete based on 55 characters.
  2. Respect Your Reader’s Time: Your reader has little time to spend on an email. Make sure that they feel their time was well spent.
  3. Invest in Building Your Own List: Take the time to build a legitimate e-mail list. It can be slow, but it is the best approach in the long-run.

See more about Small Business Marketing in Chelsea. If you are more interest in the borough, you can see our Small Business Marketing in Manhattan. If you want the full city, you can see our Small Business Marketing in NYC.

How to Adapt Our Small Business SEO Tips for Chelsea

Aside from all the general tips above, here are some specific actions you can take based on the three key elements of local search algorithms:


All of this assumes that you have completed your keyword research and developed your keyword list. If you have not, this section will be more effective once you do. Please see our previous post on digital marketing in Chelsea and then come back.

Go through your keywords list and select those which are good descriptors of your business. If it were me, I would use something like “digital marketing agency”, “seo services”, for example. Then make a list of the neighborhoods you service, for example “seo services Jay Street”.

Now comes the harder part, that is frankly a bit tedious. For each combination, see if you can create a somewhat unique post that’s 500-1000 words for that keyword. For us, it is a post like this. I try to write a post that helps my potential clients learn something or do something they didn’t know they could. 


Now, this is the good part. If you do write quality posts for these keywords, you will be raising your prominence. Google knows that all these areas are near Chelsea. So, for each good post you write, you help raise your prominence on a given topic in a given location.

Prominence is also helped by the basic techniques I mentioned earlier, such as being a part of local business groups, e.g. the Manhattan Chamber of Commerce or Neighborhood Associations. Any local listing helps.


This is why I like the blog technique because it hits all three key areas. If your keyword is a descriptor of what you do and the neighborhood is one you serve, it is highly likely that you will score points on relevance.

Finding the right SEO for your small business in a neighborhood like Chelsea can be a crucial way to get your company noticed online.

These same tools would apply if you want to target local SEO in NYC