March 19, 2021

How to Connect with Your Social Media Audience in NYC

It’s not always easy to find your audience on social media platforms. Each caters to a separate niche. We show you how to mix the platforms to maximize your reach.

Know Your Target

It’s incredibly important to understand your target audience in granular detail in order to not only reach but to motivate them.

Market segmentation is a powerful tool to help you find pockets of the market that are distinct from the rest of the market, share a core set of values or needs, and are motivated by similar things.

Using your market segmentation, you can create a target persona. This a personification of an average member of the group. You can different personas within a target market in NYC if there are differences in gender, location, or media consumption.

social media audience NYC market segmentation

This short video gives a high-level overview of how to build a persona.

The reason you might have a different persona per platform is due the platforms underlying demographic usage patterns. For example, Twitter skews older than Instagram or TikTok. Knowing those demographic differences can allow you to be more authentic and relatable.

Mine Your Social Media Platforms to See How Well They Match

Each social media platform has demographic reporting data you can see about your followers. This is an important step to ensure that your initial persona is matching your audience. Social media agencies can really help you here.

Privacy Laws are Making the Job Much Harder

With privacy constraints, this is becoming harder to do. For example, Twitter removed their audience insights in January 2021. Therefore, you will probably have to use some third party software program to pull the demographics for you. 

There are several quality programs you can use. A quick search of social media monitoring software can get you started. Each has its pros and cons. Choosing one is more an issue of preference than performance.

To Confirm Your Persona - First Look at Age and Gender

Once you have a program in place and linked your social accounts to it, you can see how each platform performs. You will probably see some variation from platform to platform. When we looked at our demographic splits, we found that:

social media audience NYC - persona segmentation

Our age and gender varied significantly between platforms. Therefore, we need to create 3 social media personas. As you can see, it is important to understand your audience demographics, so you can share the right content to drive engagement.

Then, Look at Geographical Regions

You can also slice the data to see if you have any variances because of location. While it surprised us to see that we had followers in other areas like California and Texas, we did not see any major differences in demographics. Our followers from New York City and Pittsburgh were identical to those from California and Texas.

Create as Many Persona Variants as are Necessary

You want to make sure that you balance the numbers of personas you have versus the effort it will take to maintain them. As a rule of thumb, I recommend only three unless the data shows the need for more.

For us, we needed three personas:

social media audience NYC - persona emily
Instagram - Emily
Young female small business owner
social media audience NYC - persona john
Facebook - John
Young male small business owner
social media audience NYC - persona mike
Twitter - Mike Older male small business owner

Now, It’s Time to Understand What Your Personas Care About

One of the great tools that you can leverage is Natural Language Processing (NLP). There are several natural language processing software packages available. They can help you take the comments or posts from your target audience and turn them into usable data.

NLP software can cluster comments around themes. These tools can also perform sentiment analysis around those themes. Some themes will have positive emotions tied to them, while others will have negative emotions.

For example, our themes looked like for older male small business owners in NYC.

social media audience NYC - content analysis

As you can see, they were discussing small business marketing and digital marketing heavily.

When talking about their business, there were several emotions that rose to the surface.

social media audience NYC - sentiment analysis

On the positive side, there was a significant amount of positive emotion around assistance and friends (support), and negative emotions centered on feeling unfairly hit by the pandemic. 

So, now, Let’s Start Connecting

There are several fun and interesting ways you can slice and dice these data. However, we will focus on the basic level in this post.

Content Creation: Persona + Topic + Sentiment + Platform

If you want to connect to your target audience, you need to match the right persona, topic, sentiment, and platform. This is the goal of a social media marketing agency when they develop social media campaigns, which are usually part of a larger marketing campaign.

social media audience NYC - emily


We would build content designed for Instagram or Instagram stories that focused on her key topics (digital marketing, lead generation, conversion). Providing facts, thought, insights, tips, motivation, etc. built around her positive emotions of (support, community, etc.) 

social media audience NYC - persona john


We would build content designed for Facebook that focused on his key topics (digital marketing, lead generation, ROI). Providing facts, thought, insights, tips, motivation, etc. built around her positive emotions of (assistance, enduring, etc.)

social media audience NYC - persona Mike


We would build content designed for Twitter or that focused on his key topics (digital marketing, small business marketing, marketing strategy). Providing solutions, tips, guidance, etc. built around reducing his negative emotions (obliterating & unfairly) 

Finding Influencers

The other simple tactic is to find the influencers on a platform that match your persona for that platform. For example, you would not have an Instagram influencer who was a male in his late 40s/early 50s. That would not be inline with your persona, it would like be less effective.

Content Calendar - Ensuring a Consistent Message

You can use the content formula provided to develop a few months’ worth of marketing content. After which, repeat this process to see if the conversation has shifted. It will every three to six months, so it’s worth repeating this process somewhere between four to six times per year.

In Summary…

If I can leave you with one thing from this discussion, it is to do your homework on your user personas. These personas can vary by locations, e.g. NYC vs. Pittsburgh vs. Texas. 

As you have seen, they often split by gender and age. Therefore, it is wise to make sure that your persona on your platform acts and speaks like the average follower on that platform. 

Nothing loses credibility faster than a mismatch between the platform persona and social media platform audience.

Enjoyed this post? Consider following us daily.

About the Author

Brian Cairns, CEO of Prostrategix Consulting. Over 25 years of business experience as a corporate executive, entrepreneur, and small business owner. For more information, please visit my LinkenIn profile

Receive Our Newsletter!

Sign-up to our newsletter by filling out your details below.

Related Posts

How To Build a Social Media Marketing Plan

¾ of Adults use social media. That's why a social media marketing plan is key. It is one of the easiest ways to connect with people. While easy, convincing is hard.

Gain More Insight!
Want a Better Small Business Social Network? Build a Marketing Calendar
Want a Better Small Business Social Network? Build a Marketing Calendar

When it comes to building a social network marketing campaign for a small business, a content calendar will be essential.

Gain More Insight!
Our Top 5 Small Business Tips for Social Marketing Implementation
Our Top 5 Small Business Tips for Social Marketing Implementation

When it comes to building a small business social marketing campaign, these tips on the implementation of the plan will likely come in handy.

Gain More Insight!

Get New Posts By Email!

Sign-up to any new posts directly sent to you by email
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Free Resources:

E-books, Courses, and Other Information

Learn More About Us

Ready To Transform Your Business?

Schedule a discovery Call and find out what ProStrategix Consulting can do for you!

Book Discovery Call!